On Point Expertise

Legal Analysis & Writing

  • For lawyers
  • For Others
  • Bio
  • Samples
  • Contact
  • Newsletter
  • Blawg
  • Deliberate Solos
  • Federal & State
  • Immigration
SoloBuildings.jpg

The Best Advice I Didn't Take (and how it led to my admission to the Bar of the U.S. Supreme Court)

July 16, 2018 by Zara Watkins in appeals, legal writing

"Drop the illusions of grandeur." Said the senior partner as he looked at me earnestly. We were sitting in his office in the Manhattan law firm I was leaving–permanently–in less than a week. I had arranged to meet with various partners to get their advice on what to do next (because the corporate law firm thing just didn't work out for me). And that was the advice he gave me. 

For years I thought it was the sagest advice ever. It was definitely exactly what I needed at that time. I was fresh out of law school, which I had chosen to go to because I (like so many young idealists) wanted to save the world. And I had just been smacked by the cold hand of reality, i.e., of life working as a lawyer in a Big Law firm. Having little idea of what to do next, or where to find my place in the legal profession, that partner was telling me to focus, be practical, and find a way to make a living without expecting too much.

Fast forward nearly 15 years, and I landed as a solo practitioner focusing on appeals, substantive motions, and oral arguments (both for my own clients and in collaboration with other lawyers). I'm competitive by nature and I adore a challenge. So I loved the challenge of making a sustainable practice doing only what I love best: creating arguments and persuading judges to accept them. But as any competitor knows, a challenge is only fun until it isn't a challenge anymore.

There is a chance of losing focus and becoming bored in any job where you do the same thing day-in-and-day-out. It's certainly true in my work, which consists of following the same process for researching, writing, and appearing for oral argument every single time. And I have a particular knack for being easily bored (I once self-diagnosed myself with CBS–Chronic Boredom Syndrome).

So when I came across a story earlier this year–about a solo practitioner who won an appeal before the U.S. Supreme Court–a spark of interest lit up my mind. I needed a new goal: to argue a case before the U.S. Supreme Court within the next ten years (and to win, of course).

As with any new goal, I set about getting started: this Spring, in a lovely and inspiring ceremony, I was sworn in to the Bar of the U.S. Supreme Court. It was an invigorating experience that reminded me of the intellectual grandeur of our profession. And of how idealistic it is to believe in the rule of law (without which none of us lawyers would have a job).

Post swearing in–a reception with the notorious RBG!

Post swearing in–a reception with the notorious RBG!

But I know enough about this profession to know that the goal I set for myself will not be an easy feat. It requires savvy issue spotting, careful curating of an argument through the lower courts, and tons and tons of practice (both writing and orally arguing). Being admitted to the USSC Bar is only the first baby step. But I love a challenge...and I love the vigorous energy that such a challenging goal brings up in me.

I never forgot that advice from the senior partner, though. When I was recently telling a friend about my new goal, I said–a bit sheepishly–that I know it's probably an illusion of grandeur to think I will argue one day in the U.S. Supreme Court. His response–also sage–was that illusions of grandeur are necessary to make anything great happen. 

And that is exactly what I needed to hear.

Want to work together on a great case? Give me a shout and tell me what you are working on. Together we can make a great winning argument.

Learn More About Zara

Sign up with your email address to receive my newsletter where I share my inspirations, tips to better your practice, and info on how we can work together.

I respect your privacy and would never share your contact info with anyone else.

Thank you for signing up to my newsletter. Look out for an email coming from zara@onpointexpertise.com. You can also check out prior newsletter issues here.

July 16, 2018 /Zara Watkins
USSC, SCOTUS, illusions of grandeur, lawyer, goals
appeals, legal writing
  • Newer
  • Older

Disclaimer: the content on this site is intended as general information for attorneys, law firms, and non-lawyers seeking appellate representation; nothing stated on this site or on the blawg should be taken or used as legal, accounting, or other professional advice; rather, it is information on how lawyers can use services from Zara Watkins, Esq. on a freelance, outsource, or outsourcing basis and how non-lawyers can engage Zara Watkins, Esq. to represent them on appeal.  None of the content contained on this site constitutes grounds to establish an attorney-client relationship, and you should not consider it as such. Updates in the law may or may not be discussed; please do not rely on any information contained on this site or the blawg as currently applicable. There is no guarantee that you will win your appeal.

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING: PRIOR RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE SIMILAR OUTCOMES.

Copyright, all rights reserved. Zara Watkins, Esq., PO Box 627, NY, NY 10274 (mailing address; home office address available upon request).